Opens in a new tab

Pae Street apartment association wins fire insurance dispute

Monday 16th November 2026 on 08:01 in Estonia

courts, Estonia, Tallinn

Harju County Court has rejected an insurer’s claim to recover fire-related compensation from an apartment association and one apartment owner in Tallinn. ERR reported that the court said insurers must act in good faith and consider all the circumstances behind a loss when seeking reimbursement.

The dispute followed a fire at a Pae Street apartment building on April 7, 2022. The insurer had paid for damage and expenses involving six apartments, then sought 145,086.26 euros from the association and one owner. The claim included apartment repairs, damaged household belongings and temporary accommodation.

The insurer argued that the fire began in a chimney serving one apartment and that fire-safety deficiencies in the building increased the damage. The court found no proof that the fire started in that chimney and did not find that the association had breached its duty to manage the building’s jointly owned property.

The court also considered that the insurer had not checked the building’s overall condition when insuring individual apartments, saying it had not regarded that condition as relevant. Yet it relied on alleged construction and fire-safety defects in seeking reimbursement. The court said this inconsistency mattered, adding that a professional insurer should identify the information it needs to assess risk and ask clear questions to obtain it. The court noted that this does not mean a technical audit is required before every insurance contract.

The court accepted that apartments and household property had been damaged and that temporary accommodation costs were justified: the building was uninhabitable after the fire, without electricity and affected by extensive dampness. It also considered whether reasonable cleaning and drying could have prevented some further damage and took into account that the building had been left unprotected after the fire. The court said that even if the association had been liable, it would have been unreasonable to make it bear the full loss and reduced any compensation to zero.

The ruling is not final. It can be appealed to Tallinn Circuit Court within 15 days of service.

Source 
(via ERR)