Horse theft plagued Estonian settlers in the Caucasus for decades
Estonian settlers’ valuable horses became targets both because of local customs and anti-colonial resentment. An overview by Aivar Jürgenson, a senior researcher at the Estonian National Museum, found that imperial authorities solved only 5% to 10% of horse theft cases, ERR reported.
In an agricultural society, losing a work animal could cause serious harm to a household. A stolen horse meant losing both the animal and valuable working time. If searches failed, work could be halted for longer. Frequent thefts also forced families to keep poorer horses, reducing productivity and worsening their financial situation.
Horse and cattle theft became a persistent, acute problem in Estonian settlements in the Sukhum district, where Estonians began settling in the 1880s. Jürgenson’s article in the journal Tuna examines the extent and seasonal patterns of livestock theft, how it was organised, the networks used by thieves, and the geographic and administrative conditions that enabled it.
The article also looks at the place of livestock theft in the customary law of the region’s Indigenous population and how their attitudes differed from those of the settlers. The cases reveal mutual distrust, slow official procedures often regarded as unfair, and authorities’ efforts to curb the thefts.
Estonian settlers complained about horse theft in handwritten accounts held by Estonian memory institutions and in letters to newspapers published in Estonia. Much of the material used in the article comes from the Kutaisi Central Archive of the Georgian State Historical Archive. In the late 19th century, the Sukhum district and its Estonian villages belonged to Kutaisi Governorate.