Court rejects challenge to Kikepera bog restoration work
Wednesday 18th November 2026 on 14:45 in
Estonia
Estonia’s Tallinn Administrative Court has dismissed a challenge by companies that co-own the Kauni property against water restoration work in the Kikepera Nature Reserve and Soomaa National Park, ERR reported. The court said the owners had not proved the work would make their land wetter or infringe their right of access.
HMG Invest and Holding OÜ and OÜ Metsakohin argued that blocking ditches and building dams could damage their forest, hinder access and reduce the property’s value. They also said the impact of the work had not been adequately assessed and that the required permits had not been issued.
The court found that the impact on the property had been sufficiently examined. Although project documents gave only brief reasons for concluding there would be no impact, that conclusion was based on detailed scientific analysis and modelling. The Environmental Board was entitled to rely on assessments by experts involved in preparing the restoration plan and project, the court said, and was not required to commission a new full assessment.
The property was excluded from the restoration area because of the owners’ opposition. Ditches serving the property, along with the ditches into which they drain, were therefore left open. The court considered it plausible that keeping them open and operational would allow drainage to continue. The owners provided no evidence to overturn that conclusion.
The court also found no proof that the owners’ access rights had been violated. Access along one forest track will worsen, but other routes will remain available. The owners have no legal basis to demand continued use of that track, the court said.
Because the owners had not established that their rights were infringed, the court did not rule on whether a building permit or an environmental impact assessment was required. The dismissal therefore does not determine whether all aspects of the restoration work are lawful. The court noted that the legal framework for authorising such work may need clarification.
The court lifted a temporary ban on work in part of the restoration area on November 18. Automatic water-level monitoring on the Kauni property, and the requirement to give the owners access to monitoring data, will remain in force until the judgment takes effect.
The ruling is not final. An appeal may be filed with the Tallinn Circuit Court within 30 days.