Prosecutors say Joller’s family doctor role is not a crime
Tuesday 17th November 2026 on 16:30 in
Estonia
Prosecutors say Social Affairs Minister Karmen Joller’s continued ownership of a family doctor patient list breaches health services law but is not a criminal offence, ERR reports. Her list includes 1,745 people, according to the Health Board.
Joller became minister in March last year and has said she will begin the process of transferring the list in January next year. The law allows a family doctor to be replaced for up to one year, or up to two years for professional training. During parental leave, replacement may continue until the leave ends.
Prosecutor’s Office public relations adviser Jukko Nooni told ERR that exceeding the maximum replacement period conflicts with the law, but is not punishable as a crime. He also said that, under the Anti-Corruption Act, restrictions on transactions do not apply to adopting a general legal act or participating in its preparation or adoption.
The Social Affairs Ministry, led by Joller, has drafted amendments that would allow a family doctor to be replaced for as long as they hold an elected office. Anastassia Kovalenko-Kõlvart, chair of the Riigikogu’s Anti-Corruption Select Committee, questioned why Joller was seeking to change the law rather than give up her patient list. She said she would convene a committee meeting to discuss the matter.
Joller has also cited the legal exception for general acts and said she receives no benefit from retaining the list. She said she continued seeing patients on a reduced basis while serving as a member of parliament, but ended her employment contract with the family medical centre before becoming a minister, as she could not continue seeing patients in government.
Joller said she has no contract with the centre and does not own part of the practice or hold a position on the board or supervisory board of an operating company or commercial association. The capitation payment goes to the family medical centre, she said, and her colleagues care for her patients under an arrangement with the centre.
The Health Insurance Fund did not consider itself able to comment before Wednesday on why Joller’s list had not been taken away or whether the arrangement was fair to her patients.