Pae 25 apartment association defeats Seesam in insurance dispute
The apartment association for Tallinn’s Pae 25 building has won a court case against insurer Seesam, which sought to recover 145,000 euros in costs after a fire destroyed the roof four years ago, ERR reported. The court dismissed Seesam’s claim, but three other court disputes over the building’s insurance remain, and half the building is still uninhabitable.
The fire destroyed the roof of the apartment building on Pae Street. Gjensidige, which insured the association, arranged for the roof and damaged top floor to be demolished before terminating its insurance contract. The company cited the fire department’s finding that the blaze started in a non-compliant fireplace chimney and that fire safety requirements had not been adequately met.
Gjensidige and Seesam, which insured individual residents’ apartments, sought to recover the demolition costs and the cost of temporary accommodation for residents from the association. During the court disputes, the building remained without a roof for an extended period, and moisture damaged the top floor.
Harju County Court ruled that the association did not have to pay Seesam’s claim. Expert assessments differed over the cause of the fire, and the court found that Seesam had not sufficiently examined the building’s condition before entering into its insurance contracts.
The court’s civil division head, Kai Härmand, said insurers should ask apartment associations the relevant questions when arranging coverage, rather than later faulting them for information the insurer had not requested. Seesam’s representatives said the company had not commissioned an audit of the whole building because it insured only individual apartments.
The main case involving Ergo, which took over Gjensidige’s contracts, has yet to be heard. Hearings are scheduled for spring, while the association and Ergo are negotiating a possible settlement, said association board member Mikk Sepp.
The Estonian Insurance Association says apartment associations are responsible for ensuring buildings are safe for residents. Its board member Lauri Pottsepp also advised associations to review their liability insurance, saying inadequate or absent coverage can leave residents or the association responsible for paying damages.